Defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional

Defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional

Doctor is an academic title that originates from the Latin word of the same spelling and meaning. The word is originally an agentive noun of the Latin verb docēre [dɔˈkeːrɛ] 'to teach'. It has been used as an academic title in Europe since the 13th century, when the first doctorates were awarded at the University of Bologna and the University of Paris 16/11/ · The full form of PhD is Doctor of Philosophy. A PhD is a doctoral research degree. In general, PhD course duration is 3 years and a student can complete it The Netherlands has one of the most impressive and prestigious university systems in Europe. It’s also a country that has developed and shared rich traditions of artistic, cultural and scientific achievement. PhD study in the Netherlands is a popular choice for many students looking to tap into

The Dutch PhD defence is a ceremony, not an examination

In the Netherlands, PhD candidates defend their dissertations during a traditional public ceremony. Although the event's festive character should be valued, PhD candidates need to be exposed to more public criticism, according to some foreign professors at TU Delft. She vividly remembers her dissertation defence inas a formal occasion dominated by the traditionally dressed examination committee. Carmona, who works at the faculty of Architecture, found it frustrating to have to explain so many 'irrelevant' issues, but believes her dissatisfaction is not unusual: 'Many of my colleagues refuse to discuss their PhD exams'.

Carmona's PhD defence took place in Delft and, besides being in English, was very much a typical Dutch ceremony. Family, friends and colleagues had gathered in one of the Aula's formal halls and saw the pedel master of ceremony lead the defence committee into the room. Nervously awaiting their return, Carmona certainly looked the part, wearing a beautiful old hat and a robe she'd made especially for the occasion.

Approximately fifteen minutes later she was told she had passed and immediately received her certificate. The official ceremony was followed by a cup of coffee and immense relief.

Bill Melody, professor at the Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, believes the Dutch Ph. defence is 'a ceremony, not an examination' defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional this 'demonstration of competence' does not measure up to the ordeal North American students must endure. In the U.

and his native Canada, a defence is a public event that takes place in a seminar room or lecture hall, where, following a thirty-minute introduction, members of the exam committee, colleagues and friends are invited to ask questions. This 'public' defence, however, is followed by a private defence behind closed doors, when examiners air their detailed criticisms of the dissertation during a rigorous examination, which can last anywhere from an hour to a day, defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional.

An 'unblemished' pass is rare; usually a candidate passes subject to certain revisions. In the worst case, a candidate must schedule a second defence, which is unthinkable in the Netherlands, where candidates probably wouldn't even fail 'if they were dumbstruck'. Moreover, the questions that will be asked are sometimes even given to the students in advance. Melody would be 'mortally embarrassed' if one of his North American students needed a second defence, because 'to be allowed to defend is the most important quality criterion.

A bad dissertation reflects very badly on the student's supervisor'. Once a student has made the necessary changes and collected the relevant signatures, officially passing a North American PhD exam is, in terms of pomp and ceremony, a non-event.

However, the yearly formal graduation ceremony compensates for the lack of festivities surrounding the PhD defence. Thousands of students graduate during this ceremony. Wearing ceremonial gowns, PhD graduates are called up on stage to accept their degrees. Melody: 'The Dutch ceremony is definitely more personal' the combination of ceremony and examination is a reflection of the different philosophies.

Half way through his PhD course, he had to defend a mini-thesis, defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional, which was given by his supervisor and one internaldepartment examiner. However, this examiner was not supposed to know the candidate too well, but in French's case, they were well acquainted: 'Before the defence he defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional to me, 'for what I'm about to do' please don't take it personally''.

The mini-defence lasted one hour and was extremely tough, defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional, but his internal examiner was pleased, explaining that the real defence couldn't possibly be more difficult.

French's final defence was a private occasion lacking all ceremony and merely involving three examiners, who asked 'very reasonable' questions for one hour. French celebrated by buying his friends Guinness at the local pub. Graduation ceremonies in the UK are similar to those in the United States. French smiles as he recalls wearing a suit and a fancy blue and purple toga, despite the hot June sunshine and his reputation as a 'scruffy sod' who loathed pompous display: 'Like the other PhD graduates, I was invited on the stage to have the vice-chancellor wrap his hands around mine'.

His certificate arrived in the post a few days later. According to Professor Giampiero Berrogi, from Italy, who works at the Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management, other European PhD defences are similar, although Dutch examination committees are larger. Swiss and German committees are usually comprised of one promoter and one or two additional readers, and the process isn't as ceremonious. Berrogi believes that the best aspects of the European and US systems should be combined: 'Somewhere in the defence process here, more scholarly challenges are needed'.

The PhD candidate should be exposed to more public criticism, but the event shouldn't lose its festive character. Melody shares this view, but advises students to 'decide on your subject first, find out who the experts in the field are, and then select a university that links you to the pioneers at the frontier.

This site uses functional and analytic cookies. These cookies are needed to let the site operate defence of phd thesis in netherlands with traditional its full potential. You can manage your preferences. Journalistic platform TU Delft Education Science Campus Opinion Short News Fill 1. Home Education. Education 30 maart - The Dutch PhD defence is a ceremony, not an examination. Share this article:.

Education Education. Het hoger onderwijs wordt niet geraakt door de nieuwe coronamaatregelen die het kabinet vanavond heeft afgekondigd. Zelfs het avondonderwijs kan doorgaan. Weer moet het kabinet strengere maatregelen nemen om het coronavirus in te dammen en de ziekenhuizen te ontzien. Wat betekent dit voor de TU Delft? Higher education is not affected by the new corona measures announced by the cabinet on Friday evening.

Even evening education can continue. Over half of the internationals studying in the Netherlands say they plan to stay on after graduating, reports the Dutch organisation for internationalisation in education. I'm okay with that Options. Zoeken Zoekterm Fill 1. Never miss a story Join the community and receive our top stories in your mailbox every week.

PhD Thesis Defense. Ioannis Georgakis

, time: 1:54:20

16/11/ · The full form of PhD is Doctor of Philosophy. A PhD is a doctoral research degree. In general, PhD course duration is 3 years and a student can complete it I choose to learn from the best. When it comes to learning how to write better, blogger.com is that company. The writers there are skillful, humble, passionate, teaching and tutoring from personal Defence Of Phd Thesis In Netherlands With Traditional experience, and exited to show you Defence Of Phd Thesis In Netherlands With Traditional the way/10() 30/09/ · List of PhD Scholarships in India & Application Timelines From academic institutions to government ministries as well as organisations, there are a large number of PhD scholarships and research fellowships offered in India